Commentary released by The Heritage Foundation makes the foolhardy claim that the Trump Administration’s proposed budget cuts to federal climate change programs are smart management, and not an attack on science. The arguments for this claim are misguided, irresponsible, and politically motivated, and they are intended to provoke mistrust in government and denial of scientific evidence about the urgent threat of global climate change for human health and national security. As such, these budget cuts are a direct attack on science, as they will eliminate critical funding for programs that will help protect us from the worst effects of climate change, and where appropriate, adapt to the changing environment. That seems like unwise, senseless management.
It is true that there are a lot of climate change-related programs in the federal government, but arguably they should be expanded, not cut. The nearly universal consensus of climate scientists indicates that global climate change is an existential threat to the global economy, quality of life, and environmental sustainability. Multiple studies published in peer-reviewed scientific journals show that 97 percent or more of climate scientists who are actively publishing in climate science agree that warming trends over the past century are extremely likely due to human activities. Statements of 18 leading scientific organizations (e.g., American Association for the Advancement of Science, U.S. National Academies of Science) have documented this consensus. While it is true that climate variability is natural, and that atmospheric concentrations of greenhouse gases have also varied historically, carbon dioxide levels have largely fluctuated between 180 and 280 parts per million (ppm), they have risen sharply since the Industrial Revolution (with the concurrent rise in global emissions). The level of atmospheric concentration of green house gases is currently over 400 ppm.
The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), which includes more than 1,300 scientists from the United States and other countries, forecasts a temperature rise of 2.5 to 10 degrees Fahrenheit over the next century, depending upon a range of possible scenarios for projected emissions. The effects of climate change are broader and more complex than the phrase “global warming” would suggest. The IPCC reports draw upon numerous global circulation models to estimate the effects of climate change, which include rising sea levels, more frequent droughts, flooding, and wildfires, ocean acidification, and an increasing in the frequency and intensity of extreme weather events, such as hurricanes. The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) has reported that while occasional heavy rains are part of natural climate variability, with rising global surface temperatures, the water cycle is speeding up, and contributing to heavier rainfall events and flooding. Many of these effects are already happening (e.g., increasing wildfires, extended drought in California, Superstorm Sandy, etc.). The impacts are hitting hardest in developing countries in tropical zones, where it is becoming difficult to grow food, and there are growing concerns about world food supplies. There may be near-term benefits to some regions of the USA (such as Michigan, which is likely to enjoy a longer growing season for agriculture), these effects are likely to be catastrophic for low-lying cities (e.g., New Orleans, Tampa, Miami, Norfolk, and Boston), cities of the arid Southwest, and agricultural regions of the West.
A federal government that has the best interests of its citizens in mind would be foolish to cut programs that aim to mitigate these effects.
It is also true that most of the federal funds for climate change-related programs are directed at clean energy technology. That is simply because the current energy economy is almost entirely powered by fossil fuels—mostly coal and petroleum—and these energy technologies are responsible for most of the greenhouse gas emissions that are contributing to global climate change. If we are to address the threat of climate change in any meaningful way, developing clean energy technology would seem to be the first place to begin. And beyond the potential of such technologies to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and mitigate the effects of climate change, they are also cleaner—that is, they do not contribute to air and water pollution that threaten human health. The World Health Organization reported that seven million premature deaths annually are linked to air pollution—one in eight of total global deaths—and that air pollution is now the world’s largest single environmental health risk. The Heritage Foundation commentary suggests that if clean energy technologies “are economically viable, there will be plenty of private sector capital available to develop them.” The oil and gas industry receives more tax breaks than any other energy sector, and oil companies are among the most profitable in the world. The mining industry still pays royalty rates that were put into law in 1872. Investing in clean energy technologies would seem to be smart economic and environmental policy. In fact, the United States was previously the world leader in the development of wind energy technology. China is now ranked first in renewable energy investment—more than double that of the USA—and combined investments by developing nations has exceeded that of developed nations. Apparently the rest of the world would disagree that such spending is “wasteful”.
Of course, the federal government is a large bureaucracy that no doubt could be more efficient in its budgeting and spending. Most organizations—in both the private and public sectors—are inefficient in some areas. But given the gravity of the threat of global climate change, I would profoundly disagree that there should be such blunt and draconian cuts to climate change-related programs—especially clean energy technologies.
Furthermore, I would disagree that international climate initiatives are “fatally flawed”. One would only need to look at the Montreal Protocol on Substances that Deplete the Ozone Layer, which was signed by 197 countries, and has been deemed successful at its goal of eliminating the production and consumption of ozone-depleting substances to limit their damage to the Earth’s ozone layer. The only flaw with previous attempts at international climate initiatives was that the USA and China refused to participate. The USA was previously seen as a world leader in global environmental responsibility, but actions such as the Administration’s decision to withdraw from the Paris climate agreement, and Trump’s refusal to budge on the issue at the recent G20 conference send a message that the country is denying the findings of science and dangerously ignoring the threat of climate change.
Much of the discourse on the role of the Environmental Protection Agency ignores some important events in American history, and reflects an ignorance of historic environmental conditions. In the mid-19th Century, over 150,000 Americans died of cholera from contaminated drinking water between 1830 and 1850. Pollution control creates residuals, like sludge, that may contain toxic chemicals so that the residuals themselves need management. Pollution events over the past century have left the USA with hundreds of toxic waste contaminated sites that must be managed to protect human health. There are 1,336 Superfund sites on the National Priorities List of contaminated sites to be managed. The Superfund program is managed by the EPA, and is responsible for cleaning up some of the nation’s most contaminated land and responding to environmental emergencies, oil spills and natural disasters. This is not wasteful spending.
In the 1960s, the Great Lakes and their tributaries were so polluted that it was not uncommon for them to catch fire. In the 1970s, parts of the Chesapeake Baywere marine dead zones—waters that were depleted of oxygen because of hypoxia and eutrophication—excessive nutrient runoff from agriculture and urban areas, and this resulted in widespread fish kills. The Trump budget would eliminate funding for the Great Lakes under the Great Lakes Restoration Initiative of the EPA, and would cut funding for cleanup efforts in the Chesapeake Bay. These restoration initiatives have been guided by scientific research, and eliminating them could be dangerous for human health and aquatic ecosystems.
Finally, it is misleading to say that there are “major problems and gaps in climate science,” and such statements represent a fundamental misunderstanding of science. There is always uncertainty in science—mostly because of confounding factors—which is why it is an ongoing and evolving pursuit of discovery. New findings spark new questions, which reduce uncertainty as scientists learn from one another (think about progress in the treatment of HIV/AIDS or various cancers, which have been successful as knowledge has advanced and uncertainty has been reduced). Climate modeling has advanced significantly, and the findings of models from research institutions in dozens of countries are coming to the same conclusions. In fact, in the past couple of decades, much of the uncertainty has been reduced as climate science has advanced, and unfortunately the new knowledge gained through those efforts has increased the threats. For example, early climate science did not fully consider the effects of feedback loops, such as the process by which melting Arctic ice reduces the reflection of heat, and actually adds to the problem of already-warming oceans, ultimately increasing the rate of sea-level rise beyond what would have been attributed to the mere warming surface temperatures. All of this doubt, denial, and accusation of “inexact science” is being stirred up by well-funded political action committees whose donors stand to be negatively affected by policies that would reduce emissions of greenhouse gases.
Wasteful spending should be a priority for reduction, but the imprudent argument that the proposed cuts of 30% or more to the budgets of the EPA or to NOAA climate programs are “smart management” simply plays to a political base that already distrusts scientists. In this way, these proposed budget cuts are precisely an attack on science, and they are aimed to stir even more distrust in government, scientists, and other experts. If we are concerned about the quality of life and well-being of future generations, funding for climate science and policy should be given very high priority.
The Heritage Foundation claims that it is “building an America where freedom, opportunity, prosperity, and civil society flourish” through “conservative public policies based on the principles of free enterprise, limited government, individual freedom, traditional American values, and a strong national defense.” Given the dire specter of global climate change and its projected impacts for the USA and the rest of the world, it is disappointing that this organization does not include science among the principles that guide its efforts. History has demonstrated that America has flourished when it has used science to develop evidence-based policies to protect human health and quality of life.