Skip to content →

The Trump Administration continues its attack on science, and it is not going well. The first 200 days of this Administration have been marked by direct and consistent confrontations with the scientific community, and no area of science has been targeted more explicitly than climate science. The assaults have included drastic cuts in the Administration’s proposed budget to federal climate change programs, the removal of climate-related information from government websites, and the apparent attempts to censor the use of the phrase “climate change” in agency documents. Scientists know that these actions are dangerous to public health, the economy, and our national security, and many are pushing back on the Administration’s attempts to muzzle them.

Academic integrity, it turns out, is really important to scientists, and the values of transparency, freedom, unbiased facts, and evidence-based decision-making are deeply engrained in a common worldview shared by the scientific community. Knowledge is advanced through the dissemination of the findings from scientific research, and scientists tend to resist attempts to silence them. Science embraces critical thinking, but there is no place for “alternative facts” in science. Scientists do not like to be censored. Scientists do not like to be told to avoid using the language of science.

Concerns about academic freedom and censorship have compelled some scientists who share these values to speak out—or rather, to leak out. A draft report by scientists from 13 federal agencies concludes that the impacts of global climate change are being felt now in regions of the US facing rising sea levels or prolonged water stress. The report was completed this year as a special science section of the National Climate Assessment, which is mandated by Congress to be conducted every four years. But some scientists involved in the Assessment were concerned about whether the Trump Administration would sign off on its release to the public. So it was “leaked”.

A draft of the report was obtained by the New York Times, and it states that “evidence for a changing climate abounds, from the top of the atmosphere to the depths of the oceans.” The report goes on to say that “many lines of evidence demonstrate that human activities, especially emissions of greenhouse (heat-trapping) gases, are primarily responsible for recent observed climate change.”

Apparently these scientists felt that the findings of the National Climate Assessment are important so that they should be released to the public, and they fear that the Trump administration could alter the report or suppress its conclusions. Their fears would not be unfounded.

In a separate leak, staff members of the Department of Agriculture’s Natural Resource Conservation Service were told to “avoid” using the phrase “climate change” in agency documents. In a series of emails obtained by the Guardian, staff members were instructed to refer to “weather extremes” instead. Other phrases, such as “climate change adaptation,” “reduce greenhouse gases”, and “sequester carbon” were also to be avoided. These phrases are part of the language and lexicon of science, and it is an affront to the very pursuit of knowledge to instruct federal scientists to avoid using particular words. This is censorship, and it is dangerous to science, and dangerous to democracy.

The Administration has been unrelentingly hostile to climate science and policy. The US was previously seen as a world leader in global environmental responsibility, but actions such as the Administration’s decision to withdraw from the Paris climate accord, and Trump’s refusal to budge on the issue at the recent G20 conference send a message that the country is denying the findings of science and dangerously ignoring the threat of climate change. The removal of data and information about climate change from federal agency websites deprives the public, including teachers and students, of valuable information regarding the state of knowledge about climate change. The Administrator of the Environmental Protection Agency denies scientific evidence that emissions of carbon dioxide contribute to global climate change.

These actions follow the Administration’s proposed budget cuts to federal climate change programs. These budget cuts are a direct attack on science, as they will eliminate critical funding for programs that will help protect the country from the worst effects of climate change, and where appropriate, adapt to the changing environment. Such actions are meant to provoke mistrust in government and denial of scientific evidence about the urgent threat of global climate change for human health and national security. The nearly universal consensus of climate scientists concludes that global climate change is an existential threat to the global economy, quality of life, and environmental sustainability.

A federal government that has the best interests of its citizens in mind would be unwise to silence scientists, remove access to information, and cut programs aimed mitigating the effects of climate change. Integrity and transparency are fundamental values in science, and when those values are tested through censorship and “alternative facts,” scientists push back.

Published in Uncategorized